Some Things I Think Are Overrated (In No Particular Order)
Tweet
- Dan Marino
- Fight Club (the book)
- The Lord Of The Rings Trilogy (the movies)
- Dr. Strangelove
- The 1960s
- Maureen Dowd
- Dane Cook
23 Responses to “Some Things I Think Are Overrated (In No Particular Order)”
GOP Rep. Spencer Bachus Facing House Ethics Probe For Insider Trading
Jennifer Aniston Reportedly Pregnant With Twins
PHOTOS: Tamara Ecclestone At The Langham Hotel
Red Front? “Center For American Freedom” Logo Echoes Communist Style
Romney Calls For Defunding Planned Parenthood, Wife Was A Donor
GOP Fundraising Email Asks Supporters To “Knock Out” Obama
Romney Comes Up Limp In Nevada
Obama Opens Lead On Romney In New Poll
Latest Entries
Why Do Liberals Support Drone Strikes?
Weekly Standard Rolls Out The Iraq Argument For Iran
Equal Polarization, My Ass
Some Crazy Stuff That Happened In World War II
Maryland Republican Campaign Funds Used To Defend Voter Suppression
The Obama Jobs Record In One Graph
Martin O’Malley All In For Marriage Equality
Newt Gingrich, Filled With More Excrement Than Your Average Politician
New Year, Powerline Still Stupid
Thanks Again
Meta
Blogroll
Disclaimer
The views on this site are mine and mine alone, and do not reflect the views of my employer, Media Matters for America
© 2000-2011 Oliver Willis
Add to that
Nicole Kidman
Western ‘democracy’ (if it was that good everyone would want it, No?)
Jessica Alba’s acting
Hugh Grant
The Matrix
The Blues brothers
Stanley Kubrick
The Lord Of The Rings Trilogy (the movies)
I think those movies got a huge boost thanks to the absolute crap job George Lucas did with his second trilogy. Then again, your average Ashton Kutcher film looks epic after watching THE PHANTOM MENACE.
I’ll agree on all but Strangelove (OW) and the Marx Bros (Bryan).
I preferred the Lord of the Rings movies to the books, aside from the ending to the last movie. I would have had Saurman attack the Shire and left out the passing over the sea stuff. The second movie blows away the second book so badly that it isn’t funny, and that’s not counting the Wizard of Oz tribute shot. The Hobbit was much better than the Lord of the Rings.
The Democratic Party is overrated. Too corporatist, too conservative, and the Republicans hold its testicles over in Abu Gharib. We lefties have to work with it, but should never be constrained by it.
Dane Cook isn’t just overrated; he sucks. “Overrated,” to me, implies, “Good, but not as good as everyone says it is.” It should apply to the singles of your favorite bands (“Money” is overrated, “I Know What I Like (In Your Wardrobe)” is overrated, “The Roundabout” is overrated, so on and so forth). Come to think of it, this could apply to Maureen Dowd as well, though she’s at least MILF eye candy.
The 60s is too broad, therefore disqualified.
My list
in no particular order
Joe Gibbs
Superman
Daschunds
Jessica Alba
Lib4–
Superman is so not overrated. Superman rules. Besides which, I think there’s a large enough contingent of people who claim Superman sucks that we can’t really classify him as overrated no matter what his actual value.
OW–
I’ll second Diamond LeGrande’s point about Dane Cook: I think for him to be overrated, at least one person would have to rate him highly. He’s one of those guys who managed to get really famous and popular, and yet you never hear anyone praise him: I think the most positive thing I’ve heard said about him is “He’s not quite as bad as everyone says he is.”
And amen to the Lord of the Rings. Those movies put me to sleep, and I love fantasy, epic films, and big battle scenes.
The Marx brothers?
You’re wrong on the ’60s ( you had to be there ). Even if you don’t like what happened during that decade, there is no doubt that more defining, important things went down in just a few short years than in any decade of my life ( I’m 60 ).
I’m still amazed and depressed that the young people of this decade are not out on the streets by the tens of thousands protesting this administration, the occupation of Iraq, and ( most importantly ) the steady dripping away of our Constitutional rights and freedoms. Being a keyboard commando is not the same as putting your physical ass on the line.
Poker.
From that, I exclude for the real game typically played between periodically between friends; that game is a fine part of the American landscape.
The reasons why ‘poker’, the online / televised bastardization are ‘overrated’ are legion.
1 – For starters, who died and made ‘Texas hold em’ or whatever they call it king? There are many fine games of poker, some classic (say 5 card or 7 card stud), some suitable for a drunken stupid late night (‘pass the trash’, wild card games), and that nonsense they play on TV tends more toward the latter.
2 – 1/2 the players use sunglasses to avoid showing the tell? Why not go ahead and let basketball players use Flubber?
I could go on. ‘Poker’ (other than real poker as noted) would have to climb 50 feet to GET to overrated.
How about Dane Cook playing poker?
I didn’t say the marx brothers. I effin love the marx brothers! If you are referring to my including western democracy, I did that just for shock value. I do think our forms of democracy in the west suck a bit, but better that than ooh, Saudi or Burma for example.
“will you marry me? Are you rich? Answer the second question first” is in my top twenty ever comedy film lines.
Dane Cook made me laugh a lot one time. That is all I need. And I agree, I never hear anyone talk him up much.
LOTR Trilogy was very entertaining to me.
Those are the two I disagree with; I didnt live in the 60′s so I cannot say anything to that.
I would like to add The Rolling Stones and (especially) Celine Dion to the list.
I’d like to add…
Dallas Cowboys
Ottawa Senators
Boston Celtics
Bryan:
How is Nicole Kidman overrated?
I don’t think the beautiful Nicole (she is very beautiful) is that good an actress IMO. I seem to remember she was on a show with Lauren Bacall, and the host called them both “screen legends” (or some such), to which they both diagreed; Bacall because she is and Kidman because she isn’t. I think she’s right. She’s a big ‘star’, but you have to act well as well to be a legend. Yes, she was good in this or that (the hours, that ghost thing), but she’s also been rather underwhelming in this or that as well (practical magic, that murdering wheatherwoman thing). Bacall, on the other hand, has brought something to every role and cameo she has ever done (again IMO). Who would I regard as a screen legend from rent times? I hear nobody ask. Well, Meryl Streep is possible, Hillary Swank too. Definitely Jodie Foster (her teenage stuff was nigh on great (especially “The little girl who lived down the lane”). It is harder now to get on that list, because they have all had to do badly written and badly conceived films, but it isn’t impossible.
rent times? Perhaps current or present, I forget.
@Duros:
The Marx Bros. overrated?
Blasphemer!
Nicole Kidman is an okay actress and a not super attractive woman. The only movie I’ve seen here in where she looked sort of sexy was The Golden Compass.
I didn’t say the marx brothers.
@Duros:
The Marx Bros. overrated?
Blasphemer!
Dude! whoa, no. I didn’t say that. Michael Maarkman said that. I think he transposed The Matrix and the Blues Brothers from Bryan.
If anything the Marx Brothers are vastly UNDERrated.
“With a little study you’ll go a long ways, and I wish you’d start now. ”
Overrated?
Angelina Jolie
American Idol
Dane Cook would need a stepladder to be overrated.
Dr. Strangelove is a brilliant film. Calling that over rated simply negates your whole list.
Underrated?
Toni Colette
Mira Sorvino
“A book is man’s best friend outside of a dog. Inside of a dog, it’s too dark to read”
If we are going to start an underrated list, I would like to put in David Goodis and Lionel White, two wonderful but basically forgotten pulp novelists from the 50′s and 60′s.